Presence2Influence
  • Overview
  • Analytics
  • Project Sites
  • Our Team
  • Collaborative Event Ethnography
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Outreach and Media

presence2influence
examining the politics of representation in global environmental governance

Human Rights and Conservation 

9/5/2016

1 Comment

 
                                                                                                                         

                                                                                                                          Written By Savannah Schulze 
             Through out many of my sessions during the WCC I have noticed a call and attention to the pursuit of human rights along side conservation efforts. While listening to a panel devoted to incorporating human rights into the management and establishment of World Heritage Sites one panelist commented “this should be a no brainer” but past histories indicate that this is not always the case when ascribing this designation. They suggest that we need to move towards a systemic rights based approach that considers these issues from the start of such designations rather than just ”firefighting” when problems erupt. We must remember that people engage in the processes of establishing World Heritage Sites because they have their own invested interests (e.g. ecotourism or economic) however we must ensure that Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) is right in there at the start securing consent from indigenous peoples and local communities. The push for profit often ends up trumping the rights or needs of indigenous peoples. When you fail to obtain consent from indigenous peoples we can do harm, not only to Indigenous Peoples, but also cause ecological harm to the site. It is affirming to see the implementation of rights-based approach to conservation within the World Heritage Convention, as well as the establishment of the IUCN WCC Resolution 047 (2012) on implementing the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 
            While the session above focused on incorporating human-rights at the institutional level or “scaling-up", another presentation given by Joseph Itongwa from the Democratic Republic of Congo reminded me of how we need to consider human rights on the ground. Joseph spoke of his work with IPACC (Indigenous Peoples of Africa Coordinating Committee) who was invited by WWF (World Wildlife Fund) to work with the indigenous peoples of CAR (Central African Republic). Their focus was to facilitate indigenous-to-indigenous capacity building and human rights training to assist the BaAka communities living in Tri-National de la Sangha Park and World Heritage Site. The BaAka face strong cultural discrimination and serious human rights violations by the state. Through various partnerships they work to provide human rights training and establish long-term monitoring capacity of indigenous and human rights in the region. Many BaAka communities live in isolated regions and are therefore unaware of international norms and rights. The designation of the park seems to have limited the BaAka’s traditional life ways and Joseph recommends that IUCN/UNESCO (International Union for the Conservation of Nature and United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) take into account the cultural world heritage of the site. And also the value of solidarity between actors as key for long term protection of such sites. A key lesson learned here is that designation alone can not ensure conservation success. 
1 Comment
Travis
9/6/2016 03:17:32 pm

I agree completely that the rights of indigenous people and ethnic minorities need an increased role in conservation and the creation of heritage sites, nature preserves, and the rules surrounding them. However, I fear that this may not always work out in the way we desire in traditional Western conservation efforts.

I live in a place where people believe nature is an obstacle to be overcome and used for the good of humanity. They also firmly believe God will continue to provide them with the things they have always accessed even though within living memory large game has almost disappeared and forestry resources are becoming scarce. What do we do in this situation? How heavy-handed or hands-off do we need to be? What role do these people, including several ethnic minorities (although they are probably not considered "indigenous" because they are "Westernized" even though they are the native inhabitants of this area... but I am really not sure how indigenous is defined... please forgive my ignorance), play in a country with an urgent need for conservation? These people depend heavily on forest resources in the lands they clear and fish in the mangroves they overharvest.

I guess the larger question is how do we include local people in conservation if the concept of conservation is unknown or contrary to cultural fundamentals? You said in this post that the BaAka people are unaware of human rights. Are they aware of land rights, a concept more novel than human rights? If they have their own land ethic and it does not jive with ours then what do we do?

Not expecting answers to any of these questions. Just what went through my own mind as I read. Feel free to let me know where I fall totally off the mark.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    In the field...

    Follow our team as we cover international environmental policy making meetings. 

    Project Leaders:
    Dr. Kimberly R. Marion Suiseeya, Department of Political Science, Northwestern University
    Dr. Laura Zanotti, Department of Anthropology, Purdue University
    Follow us on Twitter 
    ​(@Pres2Influence)

    Archives

    December 2019
    November 2019
    August 2018
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015

    Categories

    All
    Reflections
    Research Process

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Overview
  • Analytics
  • Project Sites
  • Our Team
  • Collaborative Event Ethnography
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Outreach and Media